The blank page is its own kind of intimidating. Especially when what you’re trying to write about is something you’ve been avoiding. You sit down with the journal, pen in hand, and then — nothing. Or worse, everything comes at once, too tangled to sort through.
That’s what these prompts are for. They give you a door to walk through. A specific question, a specific angle — and suddenly the writing has somewhere to go.
You don’t have to use all five. You might get three sentences into the first one and realize you have fifteen pages to write. That’s exactly right. Follow that.
One rule: don’t edit yourself. This writing is for you. It doesn’t have to be organized, complete, or make sense to anyone else. The value is in the honesty, not the craft.
Prompt 1: What are you actually carrying?
Not what you think you should be feeling, not the version you’d tell someone at a dinner party. What’s actually there when you sit quietly with yourself?
Name it as specifically as you can. Not “guilt” — but guilt about what, exactly? Not “regret” — but regret over which moment, which choice, which version of yourself?
The more specific you get, the more useful this becomes. Vague pain is hard to work with. Named pain has edges you can actually touch.
Prompt 2: What would you say to a friend who had done what you did?
Write the conversation. Imagine your closest friend sitting across from you and telling you exactly what you’ve been telling yourself. Everything — the mistake, the shame, the feeling of being fundamentally flawed.
Now write what you’d actually say back to them. What would you actually say?
Most people find this jarring. They would not say to their friend a single thing they’ve been saying to themselves. That gap — between how you’d treat someone you love and how you treat yourself — is exactly where the work is.
Prompt 3: What do you think this mistake says about you?
Not what it actually says. What do you believe it says? What verdict have you quietly rendered?
Write it down, even if it’s harsh. Especially if it’s harsh. Because most of us are operating under beliefs about ourselves that we’ve never examined — we’ve just accepted them as facts. Putting them on paper is the first step to seeing that they’re beliefs, not truths.
Once you’ve written the verdict, ask: is this actually true? Or is this the harshest possible interpretation of what happened?
Prompt 4: What does this situation need from you?
Not what does your inner critic need. Not what would make other people feel better about what happened. What does this situation — honestly, practically — need?
Sometimes it needs an amends. Sometimes it needs a behavior change. Sometimes it needs grief — just acknowledging that something real was lost. Sometimes it needs nothing more than your honest acknowledgment that it happened, followed by a decision to move differently.
Punishment is almost never on the list of what’s actually needed. That’s worth noticing.
Prompt 5: What would be different if you forgave yourself?
This is the one most people skip, because it feels presumptuous. Like you haven’t earned the right to imagine it yet.
Write it anyway. Imagine your life six months from now if you’d actually done this work — if the thing you’re carrying now wasn’t weighing you down anymore. What would be different? What would you be able to do, feel, be, give, risk, try?
That picture — that’s what you’re moving toward. Keep it somewhere you’ll see it.
Pick one of these prompts — the one that makes you most uncomfortable. Set a timer for 10 minutes. Write without stopping. See what comes.
Forgiving You gives you the complete roadmap — 23 honest, practical keys for real people with real regrets.
Get the Book → ← Back to Blog